Guitar Hero, eat your heart out.
This game is, by far, one of the greatest Flash games ever created. A gem like this one isn't made every day. I would have felt incomplete if I hadn't beaten the entire game before reviewing this.
The graphics have improved incredibly since the second Guitar Maniac. The guitars look finer, the backgrounds and arrows look more smooth, and the beach menu picture fits very well with the rest of the game. Everything was laid out so well, too. I wasn't ever distracted when the maniac stickman floated while I was playing, and its nice to finally see all the arrows, letters, and numbers on their own bars.
I don't see why so many people are complaining about the controls. People say that having the F as an extra letter was a huge downside. I love having eight keys to press. It adds to the difficulty without making it too difficult. Also, I prefer the 1234 keys over the ASDF keys, mostly because holding the keyboard like a guitar is pretty much the greatest thing ever. I can't imagine why anyone wouldn't want to play this game without holding the keyboard like a guitar.
To add to all my comments about the controls, I'll also have to say that the programming was very well-done. Every arrow and long note fit perfectly with the songs, and the note-hitting had just the right sensitivity. I've tried making my own rhythm games before. It is certainly not easy. I don't even make anything fancy. You, sir, have a gift.
The songs weren't perfect, but they were still all pretty catchy, and although they didn't have a lot of variety, they still had enough to keep my interest. The singing in a few of the songs was below par. . . But that's not your fault. The game is still amazingly fun. My favorite song would have to be the very catchy Mars Bars and Mentos. I might have to download that one really soon.
This game is more addicting than just about anything else I've ever played. I play this for hours and hours a day until my wrist aches, my fingers grow numb, and my ears start ringing. I'm pretty sure I've spent more time playing this game than I have spent playing Super Smash Bros. Brawl. It has more replay value, as well.
Anyone who says this game deserves less than a 10 out of 10 is obviously insane. This is--without a doubt--better than Guitar Hero. I love this game.